Superfluities Redux

by George Hunka
Artistic director, theatre minima

A Theatre Surrounds a City:
Vienna's Burgtheater


Thursday, 21 January 2010

Television: The Audition

NOTE: In the New York area, The Audition will repeat on WNET Channel 13 at 2.30am on Friday 22 January and at 12noon on Sunday 7 February, and on WLIW Channel 21 at 3.00pm on Sunday 7 February. Set your DVRs accordingly.


The Audition, a two-hour film by Susan Froemke, follows the day-to-day lives of several opera singers in their twenties as they prepare for the Metropolitan Opera's National Council Auditions. Those who win have the opportunity to launch their careers, and even those who do not have the opportunity to sing from the Metropolitan Opera stage, accompanied by the Met Opera orchestra (perhaps the greatest in the world today), to a paying public.

The young singers demonstrate that opera singing, as an art form, remains in brilliant health, even as a more philistine, barbaric cultural life may relegate opera to the wayside as an elite unnecessary luxury. Of course, it is not — the human voice, as a musical instrument capable of extraordinary and sublime expression of the extremes of passion, comedy, suffering and desire, is irreplacable, as indeed are the works that offer that expression a disciplined outlet. And discipline, as well as devotion to the art and the repertoire, is at the center of the audition process. Perhaps the most memorable sections of the documentary are those which take place during coaching sessions. Those who have seen Topsy-Turvy, Mike Leigh's fictionalized account of the premiere of The Mikado, will recognize the extraordinary attention to detail and tentative hope (as well as profound self-criticism) that engages those within the rehearsal room. These men and women at work (and certainly singing for these auditioners is a profession, not a career) make the populist dreams of American Idol look like a high-school talent show. While all of the singers are influenced by the tradition of opera singing (they are unmiked and take from the history of the form bits and pieces of performance tradition), nonetheless their art is highly personal, as several of the coaches take pains to point out. The best of them indeed reveal themselves through their singing, an intimate revelation that demonstrates the ability of discipline and craft to release what can finally be called an aesthetic expression of some genius; this comes out most clearly in those moments when the singers perform unaccompanied, with the bare voice. Viewers are also privy to the judging process: an uncompromising, unsparing discussion of the virtues and vices of the individual competitors.

Except for the to-camera interviews, The Audition utilizes hand-held cameras and the fly-on-the-wall techniques of a Frederick Wiseman documentary, but these are shined and edited to a very high gloss indeed (and, as a documentary made with the support of the Met Opera itself, serves perhaps inevitably as a two-hour commercial for the Met). The film, however, is immediately engaging; it doesn't take long before favorites emerge, and you do root for your own. More than anything else, this is testimony that opera continues to be a living art form, the human voice raised to a high pitch of discipline and craft as well as spirit an irreplacable instrument. And it does have its poignant conclusion, communicated in a brief title card at the very end of the film.

The Audition premiered nationwide on the PBS Great Performances series last night, and as usual with PBS programs, it will be rerun at various times on PBS stations over the next few weeks. A trailer for the film is below.

Posted in /Music
Permanent link to this story